Sex versus Survival: The Life and Ideas of Sabina Spielrein
Who was Sabina Spielrein? Her dramatic life story is most famous for her notorious affair with Carl Jung, dramatised in the film A Dangerous Method starring Keira Knightley. Yet she was a woman who overcame family and psychiatric abuse to become an original thinker in the field of sexual psychology and psychotherapy.
Drawing on close readings of Spielrein’s diaries, professional papers and correspondence, Sex Versus Survival is the first biography to put her life and ideas at the centre of the story. John Launer examines Spielrein’s tumultuous affair with Jung and its influence on both of their lives and intellectual journeys, and her key role in the rift between Carl Jung and Sigmund Freud, and in the development of psychoanalysis.
A Russian Jew, who lost her life in the Holocaust in 1942, Spielrein’s innovative theories have chiefly been suppressed because of her gender. Sex Versus Survival is a significant stage in the rediscovery of the life and ideas of an extraordinary woman and an acknowledgment of her prominent role in the history of psychology.
Order 'Sex versus Survival' in the UK and Europe here
For researchers: a complete Spielrein bibliography appears at the bottom of this page.
‘Sabina Spielrein has been presented to the world as an erotic go-between linking Freud and Jung in the steamy days of the beginnings of psychoanalysis. In this remarkable, ground-breaking work, John Launer shows just how distorted and limited a view this is of a woman who was a pioneer of psychoanalysis and of scientific thinking in psychology. With grace and scholarly passion, Launer offers a radical new biography that places Spielrein where she belongs – as a figure of majorimportance in twentieth century thought.’ Professor Stephen Frosh, Birkbeck College, London and author of For and Against Psychoanalysis
“Dr. Launer argues cogently. and at times passionately. that Spielrein was not only an influence on Freud and Jung but an originating, and honestly female, analyst in her own right . . .The account of her anonymous end, in the Holocaust, is painfully moving.” D. M. Thomas, author of The White Hotel
‘This wonderful book is the first full-length biography in English of Sabina Spielrein. Mainly remembered, if at all, as someone who had an affair with Carl Jung, when she was a patient of his, she was also, as John Launer reveals, a highly original thinker whose work is only now becoming appreciated.’ Professor Michael J. Reiss, Institute of Education, University of London
‘An eminently readable, detective story-like history of the early years of psychoanalysis and the fascinating woman at its heart. Spielrein’s intuition of a trade-off between survival and reproduction is now a cornerstone of evolutionary theory. But for sexism, anti-Semitism, World War I, Stalinism, and the Holocaust, psychoanalysis might long ago have been grounded in our only scientific theory of life.’ Professor James Chisholm, University of Western Australia and author of Death, Hope and Sex: Steps to an Evolutionary Ecology of Mind and Morality
'This is an absorbing account which makes imaginative use of documents' Times Literary SupplementFull review
In this gripping, archive-based, detective-like tale, Launer debunks depictions by Cronenberg and others of Spielrein, her affair with Jung, and Jung's troubles on this account with Sigmund Freud' Times Higher Education Supplement Full review
'Launer is not just Spielrein's biographer, he is her champion. He gives the neglected female at last the place she deserves in the development of the talking therapies' Jewish ChronicleFull review
'An impressively researched, documented, and readable biography. This is long overdue but worth the wait.' Jewish Book WorldFull review
'I'm impressed by the humane dignity with which he recounts her lurid life' Spectator Full review
'An excellent book and a labor of love, a gripping account of Spielrein's life and work, illuminated by a narrative of contemporaneous historical events.' Journal of American Psychoanalytical Association Full review (Athens password needed).
'This memorable book finally gives [Spielrein] the recognition she deserves.' The Lady Full review
'An authoritative and riveting biography' World Association for International Studies Full review
'An impressively researched, documented, and readable biography, this is long overdue but worth the wait.'—Library Journal (Starred Review) Full review
'Launer’s portrayal of Spielrein is a loving tribute to a visionary woman whose ideas were ahead of their time…an engrossing biography that shines a light on the trails blazed by this fascinating woman.' Psychoanalytic Review Full review (Athens password needed)
'[Launer's] position allows him vividly and with great sensitivity to portray the family background of Spielrein, the circumstances of her mental suffering and deterioration, her time as a patient at the Burghölzli (the mental hospital in Zurich), her medical, psychoanalytical and educational career, and her collaboration with many of the iconic personalities of the early twentieth century' Scandinavian Psychoanalytic Journal Full review (Athens password needed)
'John Launer's excellent Sex versus Survival' ... offers a timely reconsideration of a woman whose life story has often been simplified.' Jewish Quarterly
'Incredibly well-researched and beautifully written….A highly positive recommendation for everyone who is interested in the history of psychology and its most influential scientists. Pick up this book and spend a few days immersing yourself in the mind and story of 20th century scientist Sabina Spielrein.' In-Mind Full review
'A forgotten psychoanalyst's fevered life. Tavistock Clinic senior staff member Launer asserts that Sabina Spielrein (1885-1942) deserves more attention for her groundbreaking work: the first study of the internal logic of schizophrenic speech, her insights into children's imaginations, and her use of Darwinian theory in her hypothesis of ‘the inseparable connection between death and sex.’ Kirkus Reviews
'John Launer's just-published biography positions itself as the definitive biography of Sabina Spielrein. Presenting new scholarship and new documentation, the readable and informative volume supersedes the partial, often sensational studies of the past.' National Psychological Association for Psychoanalysis News and Reviews
'Sex Versus Survival would make a valuable addition to many curriculums. And Launer writes well for the layperson, too, explaining psychological principles throughout the book ...This is an approachable biography for anyone interested in the beginnings of psychoanalysis — and in strong women in the sciences, who did and still do face adversity.' PsychCentral Full review
'This biography is an invaluable resource for understanding Spielrein’s significance, her progressive thinking, and her groundbreaking contributions to the history of psychoanalysis.' Publishers Weekly Full review
'In Sex versus Suvival, John Launer attempts to fill in the missing pieces of Spielrein’s life, while simultaneously elevating her many achievements in the fields of psychology and psychoanalysis ... Using hospital records, her own diaries and other secondary sources, this work presents a story that is remarkably antithetical to the particularly ridiculous and deservedly eschewable David Cronenberg version of Spielrein’s life (A Dangerous Method)). Launer attempts to illuminate the components of a life that have suffered erasure and weak interpretation. He does so with a clear and measured depiction of his subject.' Gender FocusFull review
'This book [is]a remarkable and an ambitious piece of research. Thanks to it, not only do we now have a first landmark biography in English of one of the most moving heroines of early psychoanalysis, but we are also given evidence of the significance and the variety of her thoughts.' Psychoanalysis and History Full review (Athens password needed)
Listen to John Launer's presentations and interviews about 'Sex versus Survival':
'Cherchez La Femme': a panel discussion based on 'Sex Versus Survival' on Saturday 21st February as part of Jewish Book Week, with Lisa Appignanesi, Stephen Frosh, Eva Hoffman, Rachel Lasserson and John Launer
Read John's invited contributions to magazines and blogs:
AC1982 =Carotenuto, A. (ed.) (1982), A Secret Symmetry: Sabina Spielrein between Jung and Freud (New York NY, Random House).
AC1986 = A. Carotenuto (ed.), Tagebuch einer heimlichen Symmetrie: Sabina Spielrein zwischen Jung und Freud (Freiburg, Kore, 1986)
BB = E. Brinkman & G Bose (eds) Sabina Spielrein: Ausgabe in 2 Bänden, Bd. 2 Ausgewählte Schriften (Frankfurt am Main, Brinkmann & Bose, 1986).
CCBW = C. Covington & B. Wharton (eds), Sabina Spielrein, Forgotten Pioneer of Psychoanalysis (Hove, Brunner-Routledge, 2003)
COTIPUB = Collection of the International Psychoanalytic University of Berlin
IJP = International Journal of Psychoanalysis
IZP = Internationale Zeitschrift für Ärtzliche Psychoanalyse (to 1920); Internationale Zeitschrift für Psychoanalyse (from 1920)
JAP = Journal of Analytical Psychology
Jahrbuch = Jahrbuch für psychoanalytische und psychopathologische Forschungen
TH = T. Hensch (ed.), Sabina Spielrein: Nimm meine Seele: Tagebücher und Schriften (Freiburg, Freitag, 2006)
Zentralblatt = Zentralblatt für Psychoanalyse und Psychotherapie
Diaries, correspondence and hospital records
AC 1986:Diary extracts 1909-1912; Letters to Freud 1909-1914; Letters from Freud 1909-1923; Letters to Jung 1911-1918; Letters from Jung 1908-1919.
TH:Diary extracts 1897-1912; Letter to mother 1905 (misdated 1908); Letters to Freud 1909; Letter drafts to Jung (probably 1907); Letter to Jung 1911; Letters from Freud 1913, 1923; Letter from father 1913; Correspondence with Jung 1918-1919; Hospital records.
AC 1982: Diary extracts 1909-1912; Letters to Freud 1909-1914; Letters from Freud 1909-1923; Letters to Jung 1911-1918.
CCBW: Referral letter from Jung 1905; Letter drafts to Jung (probably 1907); Letters from Jung 1908-1919; Hospital records. Also includes extracts from correspondence in essays by Graf-Nold, Lothane and Richebächer.
JAP,2001, vol. 46: Referral letter from Jung 1905; Letters from Jung 1908-19; Hospital records.
‘Über den psychologischen Inhalt eines Falles von Schizophrenie (Dementia praecox)’ [On the psychological content of a case of schizophrenia], Jahrbuch,1911, vol. 3, pp. 329-400 (reprinted in BB, pp. 11-93).
*a. ‘Die Destruktion als Ursache des Werdens’ [Destruction as the cause of coming into being], Jahrbuch,1912, vol. 4, pp. 465-503 (reprinted in BB, pp. 97-144). In English: JAP,1994, vol. 39, pp. 155-86.
b. ‘Über Transformation’ [On transformation], Zentralblatt, 1912, vol. 2, p. 478 (reprinted in BB, pp. 238-40). In English: Minutes, pp. 329-31.
c. ‘Beiträge zur Kenntnis der kindlichen Seele’ [Contributions to an understanding of the child’s mind], Zentralblatt,1912, vol. 3, pp. 57-72 (reprinted in TH, pp. 146-52).
a. ‘Mutterliebe’, [Mother love] Imago, 1913, vol. 2, pp. 523-4.
b. ‘Das unbewußte Träumen in Kuprins “Zwiekampf ”’ [The unconscious phantasies in Kuprin’s ‘Duel’], Imago, 1913, vol. 2, pp. 524-5. In English: JAP,2001, vol. 46, p. 201 (reprinted in CCBW, pp. 263-4).
*c. ‘Die Schwiegemutter’ [The mother-in-law], Imago, 1913, vol. 2, pp. 589-92 (reprinted in TH , pp. 158-62). In English: JAP,2001; 46, pp. 201-20 (reprinted in CCBW, pp. 267-70).
d. ‘Traum von “Pater Freudenreich”’ [The dream from ‘Pater Freudenreich’], IZP,1913, vol. 1, pp. 484-6 (reprinted in BB, pp. 147-52).
e. ‘Selbstbefriedigung in Fussymbolik’ [Self-gratification with foot symbolism], Zentralblatt,1913, vol. 3, pp. 263.
a. ‘Zwei Mensesträume’ [Two menstrual dreams], IZP, 1914, vol. 2, pp. 32-4.
*b. ‘Tiersymbolik und Phobie einem Knaben’ [Animal symbolism and a boy’s phobia], IZP, 1914, vol. 2, pp. 375-7. In English: JAP,2001, vol. 46, pp. 525-7 (reprinted in CCBW, pp. 264-7).
c. ‘Die vergessene Name’ [The forgotten name], IZP,1914, vol. 2, pp. 383-4.
‘Die Äußeungen des Ödipuskomplexes im Kindesalter’ [The utterances of the Oedipus complex in childhood], IZP,1918, vol. 4, pp. 44-8.
*a. ‘Zur Frage der Entstehung und Entwicklung der Lautsprache’ [On the question of the origin and development of speech], IZP,1920, vol. 6, p. 401. In English: IJP, 1920, vol. 1, pp. 359-60.
b. ‘Renatschens Menschentstehungstheorie’ [Renatschen’s theory of creation], IZP,1920, vol. 6, pp. 155-7 (reprinted in TH, pp. 178-9).
c. ‘Das Schamgefühl bei Kindern’ [The sense of shame in children], IZP 1920, vol. 6, pp. 157-8.
b. ‘Das schwache Weib’ [The weak woman], IZP,1920, vol. 6, p. 158.
e. ‘Resenzion: Isaak Spielrein, Über schwer zu merkende Zahlen und Rechenaufgaben. Ein Beitrag zur angewandten Gedächtnislehre’ [Review: Isaac Spielrein. On numbers that are difficult to retain, and calculation tasks. A comment on the applied science of memory], IZP,1920, vol. 6, pp. 172-4 .
f. ‘Verdränkte Munderotik’ [Displaced oral eroticism], IZP,1920, vol. 6, pp. 361-2.
a. ‘Russische Literatur. Bericht über die Fortschritte der Psychoanalyse in den Jahren 1914-1919’ [Russian Literature. Report on the progress of psychoanalysis in the years 1914-1919], Beihefte der IZP, 1921, vol. 3, pp. 356-65.
b. ‘Schnellanalyse einer kindlichen Phobie’ [Brief analysis of a child’s phobia], IZP,1920, vol. 7, pp. 473-4.
*a. ‘Die Entstehung der Kindlichen Worte “Papa” und “Mama”’ [The origin of the child’s words ‘Papa’ and ‘Mama’], Imago,192 vol. 8, pp. 345-67 (reprinted in BB,pp. 153-80; also in TH, pp. 180-203). In English: CCBW, pp. 289-309 , tr. B. Wharton.
b. ‘Qui est l’auteur du crime?’ [Who committed the crime?], Journal de Genève,vol. 93, 15 January 1922.
c. ‘Schweiz: Die Genfer psychoanalytische Gesellschaft’ [Switzerland: The Geneva Psychoanalytic Society], IZP,vol. 8, pp. 234-5
d. ‘Briefmarkentraum’ [A stamp dream], IZP,1922, vol. 8, pp. 342-3.
e. ‘Psychologisches zum Zeitproblem’, Bericht über den V11. Internationalen Psychoanalytischen Kongreß in Berlin (25-27. Sept. 1922) [Psychology of the problem of time. Report of the 7th International Psychoanalytic Congress in Berlin], IZP,1922, vol. 8, pp. 496-7.
a. ‘Quelques analogies entre la penseé de l’enfant, celle de l’aphasique et la penseé subconsciente’ [Some analogies between thinking in children, aphasia and the unconscious mind], Archives de Psychologie,1923, vol. 18, pp. 305-22 (reprinted in: Delafosse 2010, pp. 161-77).
b. ‘Die Zeit im unterschwellingen Seelenleben’ [Time in the unconscious mind], Imago,1923, vol. 9, pp. 300-17 (reprinted in BB, pp. 183-210; also in TH,pp. 207-22).
c. ‘Die drei Fragen’ [The three questions], Imago,1923, vol. 9, pp. 260-3.
*d. ‘Rêve et vision des étoiles filantes’ [A dream and a vision of shooting stars], IJP 1923, vol. 4, pp. 129-32. In English: JAP,2001, vol. 46, pp. 211-14.
*e. ‘L’automobile: symbole de la puissance male’ [The motor car as a symbol of male power], IJP,1923, vol. 4, p. 128. In English: JAP,2001, vol. 46, pp. 209-10.
f. ‘Ein Zuschauertypus’ [A spectator type], IZP,1923, vol. 9, pp. 210-11 (reprinted in TH, pp. 204-6).
g. ‘Die Gedankengang bei einem zweieinhalbjährigen Kind. Schweizerische Gesellschaft für Psychoanalyse. Sitzung am 13. Januar 1923’ [The train of thought in a two-and-a-half-year-old child. Session of the Swiss Psychoanalytical Association, 13 January 1923], IZP,1923, vol. 9, pp. 251-2.
‘Einige kleine Mitteilungen aus dem Kinderleben’ [Some brief comments on childhood], Zeitschrift für Psychoanalytische Pädagogik,1927/8, vol. 2, pp. 95-9.
‘K’dokladu Doktora Skal’kovskovo’ [On Dr Skal’kovski’s Lecture], Trudy 1-vo Sovyeshchaniya Psikhiatrov i Nevropatologov Severo-Kavkazskovo Kraya, Rostov na Donu, 1929 [Proceedings of the 1st Congress of Psychiatry and Neuropathology of the North Caucasus Region, Rostov-on-Don, 1929] . In German:BB, pp. 205-12; also in TH, pp. 224-30.
‘Kinderzeichungen bei offenen und geschlossenen Augen’ [Children’s drawings with open and closed eyes], Imago,1931, vol. 17, pp. 359-91, tr. from Russian by N.A. Spielrein.